Log in

View Full Version : Trans issues on soap Hollyoaks



Cultural Revolution
23rd November 2010, 19:26
http://www.pinknews.co.uk/images/jasonhollyoaks.jpg

Channel 4 soap Hollyoaks is to introduce a storyline about a trans boy.
The show, known for dealing with social issues including homosexuality, is to chart the progress of 15-year-old Jason Costello, as he transitions from being a girl.

The character is to be played by 23-year-old actress Victoria Atkin.
Jason will first be seen as Jasmine, who has always felt like a boy and dresses as one in secret.

Hollyoaks producers are taking advice from a number of trans teenagers, including 17-year-old Benson Bell from Cumbria, who was born female but has been treated as a boy by his friends for the last few years.

Benson told the Guardian: People still shout abuse at me in the street.
They call me a lesbian and I always think, You could at least call me a tranny. Get it right.

On the storyline, he said: I hope theyll show the shyness of it. That youre always on edge, wondering if other people think youre a boy or a girl. Its very depressing as well, to be honest.

But my hope is that this programme is so big, people will realise they cant hide from it any more and pretend its not happening. I hope they realise its not wrong and its not something you put on or that you want to do. Youre born with it.

Series producer Paul Marquess, said the storyline would not be sensationalist.
He said: Yes, thats a pitfall but I think weve avoided it.

I grew up gay in Belfast in the 1970s when there was no one to talk to, no positive role models, no gays on Corrie. I knew that absolute isolation of not knowing who to turn to. So its not about ratings.

Its about how people are affected by this.

Victoria will hit screens as a girl on August 2nd and appears for the first time four days later as Jason.

Coronation Street is currently the only soap to have a permanent trans character. Hayley Cropper, played by Julie Hesmondhalgh, first appeared on the street in 1998.

Obs
23rd November 2010, 19:35
Hollyoaks is fucking terrible.

Cultural Revolution
23rd November 2010, 20:12
I do not agree, though i will defend to the death your right to say it.

OK. so, despite Obs "trolling", anyone think this is a good thing, i remember when the guy who plays Ste in hollyoaks came out as gay, like 200 people left messages on the chanel 4 page saying it gave them courage to come out and made them feel better about alienation that coming out brings between them and their families.

I think transphobia is rampant in all societies, wether its some british scrote calling trans people freaks, or "ladyboys" in the phillepines being treated as commodities.

Is it just me, or should LGBT rights be a big part of the lefts agenda?

Mr.Awesome
23rd November 2010, 20:52
Sex change is a pretty big decision. IMO it shouldn't really be encouraged to youngsters in this way. Don't get me wrong, but as far as I'm concerned, although you could argue homosexuality is natural I can't see how you could argue that this is natural. Now if people want to have sex change thats fine by me but I don't think it should be advised to young people like this. Its a really big decision which you could easily regret later and a lot of people do.

I am fine with supporting gays and lesbians but this is something slightly different. Now that doesn't mean its wrong at all :P

No doubt I'll get flamed for this but I don't mean to offend anyone :s

Cultural Revolution
24th November 2010, 00:51
Well, most trans people have felt the way they do since being very very young, as they have the gender of say a man/woman but the sex of say woman/man, so using the old, "they might regret it later", is just a mask to hide peoples transphobia.

And the transboy in Hollyoaks does not get a sex change, he just has a storyline on a major soap, which is great, as trans youth often feel isolated and alone, and this might be a source of, if not hope, maybe something they can relate to.

And actually Homosexuality and Transexuality are completely natural, there are gay communities in nearly all species, and science proves you can have the gender of one and the sex of another, so how is it not natural to have surgery to match your gender and sex?

Aeval
27th November 2010, 10:06
Sex change is a pretty big decision. IMO it shouldn't really be encouraged to youngsters in this way. Don't get me wrong, but as far as I'm concerned, although you could argue homosexuality is natural I can't see how you could argue that this is natural. Now if people want to have sex change thats fine by me but I don't think it should be advised to young people like this. Its a really big decision which you could easily regret later and a lot of people do.

I am fine with supporting gays and lesbians but this is something slightly different. Now that doesn't mean its wrong at all :P

No doubt I'll get flamed for this but I don't mean to offend anyone :s

I watched the first few episodes of this storyline, don't have a TV anymore though so I dunno what's happened since, but I'm pretty sure they aren't "encouraging" people to have sex changes. The programme is simply showing some of the problems trans people face, like even before Jason came out to his family as a boy he was having problems just being a "tom-boy"; his Dad is incredibly controlling, wouldn't let him go out (when his brothers obviously could), couldn't hang out with boys, constantly being forced to wear "girly" clothes - it seemed quite a good storyline because it also draws attention to the way young people are treated completely differently based on their gender.

As for whether transsexuality is natural or not - well most doctors think it is and they've come up with many possible causes for it (which you find easy enough by googling :) ) and actually it's rather a small number of people who regret it later in life, certainly a lot smaller number than the amount of people who end up trying to commit suicide because they feel so totally alone, so I think having the issue dealt with in a popular soap for young people is going to have some positive impact :)