Log in

View Full Version : Israel assassinates Hamas commander



mosfeld
18th September 2010, 00:39
Israel assassinates Hamas commander

http://arabnews.com/middleeast/article140972.ece/REPRESENTATIONS/large_620x350/mid_hamas.jpg

Palestinians carry the body of Hamas military commander Iyad Shilbayeh during his funeral in the Nur Shams refugee camp near the West Bank town of Tulkarmon Friday. (Reuters)

By MOHAMMED MAR'I & HISHAM ABU TAHA | ARAB NEWS
Published: Sep 17, 2010 23:34 Updated: Sep 17, 2010 23:34

RAMALLAH/ GAZA CITY: Israeli forces raided the West Bank refugee camp of Nour Shams, to the east of Tulkarm, early Friday and killed a Hamas commander in cold blood, Palestinian sources said.

The sources told Arab News that the Israeli forces shot 37-year-old Iyad As’ad Abu Shilbayeh thrice at point-blank range and then delayed his medical treatment. Shilbayeh was a commander in Al-Qassam Brigades, the military wing of Hamas.

Narrating the sequence of events, Mohammed Shilbayeh, Iyad's brother, said dozens of military vehicles raided the camp at 2 a.m. He said the raiders used him (Mohammed) as a human shield during the raid. They blew up the bedroom door and shot Iyad three times — once in the neck and twice in the chest — while he was in bed.

The Israelis seized the body of Iyad before allowing the Palestinian forces to take it back to the family in the morning, Mohammed said.

Shilbayeh's wife and children were visiting other members of his extended family in the West Bank city of Jenin.

Palestinian security sources said Israeli forces also arrested 15 people from the camp, most of them members and supporters of Hamas.

An Israeli Army spokesman said that the troops were arresting "terror suspects in the refugee camp when the shooting occurred." He said that during the operation Shilbayeh began running toward the soldiers in a menacing manner. He did not heed their calls to stop, and once the soldiers determined they were in clear danger, they opened fire.

Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad strongly condemned the "assassination." In a press statement, he said: "This assassination is a dangerous escalation, and undermines the credibility of the already shaky peace process."

Hamas, which controls the Gaza Strip, accused Palestinian security forces of helping Israel in "assassinating" Shilbayeh, who it said was interrogated by security services loyal to Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas two days ago.

"The blood of our martyr will be a curse that will follow the occupation and the traitors," the movement said in a statement.

Salah Al-Bardwil, a spokesman for Hamas, said the killing was an "attempt to cover up negotiations." "These negotiations will lead to many important concessions," Al-Bardwil warned, saying that the assassination was part of an Israeli plan to divert attention from “the concessions Palestinian negotiators were making."

He was alluding to the latest round of negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians that concluded in Jerusalem on Wednesday.

Despite the fanfare with which the direct negotiations between the parties were launched in Washington early this month, the talks seem to be going nowhere. On Friday, Israel reiterated its refusal to extend curbs on settlement building that expire this month.

"The prime minister has not changed his position on this issue, there is no question of extending the moratorium," a senior Israeli government official said.

The decision not to renew the moratorium, which does not cover annexed east Jerusalem, was taken this week by the Forum of Seven top Cabinet ministers, according to the daily Israel Hayom, which is close to the government. That decision was communicated to US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, who was in the Middle East this week in a bid to push the peace process forward, the newspaper reported.

— With input from agencies

http://arabnews.com/middleeast/article141110.ece

mosfeld
18th September 2010, 01:20
Hamas vows vengeance over Shilbayeh killing

Group confirms man killed during IDF raid near Tulkarem was senior operative; blames Israel, PA for conspiracy. Ramallah denounces killing, ups security alert in West Bank

http://www.ynetnews.com/PicServer2/24012010/2767904/EL-PALESTINIANS-CON045470_hh.jpg

Hamas on Friday threatened retaliation over the killing of Iyad abu Shilbayeh, formerly a senior operative in the organization, who was killed during an IDF raid east of the West Bank city of Tulkarem overnight.

Hamas accused Israel and the Palestinian Authority of conspiring to kill Shilbayeh, who they claimed was imprisoned and tortured by the PA several times.

Hamas military spokesman in Gaza Abu Obeida confirmed Shilbayeh was a member of the group's armed wing: "The blood of our martyr will be a curse that will follow the occupation and the traitors," he said, referring to Hamas' rivals in the Western-backed Palestinian Authority, which has ruled only the West Bank since losing control of the Gaza Strip, to Hamas militants in 2007.

Hamas spokesman Salah Bardawil told the Palestinian Ma'an News Agency that the "resistance is capable of striking harshly at the occupation. Our battle with the occupation is not just about action and retaliation. It is a fateful battle that will never end."

Another spokesman, Sami Abu Zuhri, said that "the murder was the result of negotiations" between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. He too blamed the PA and Fatah, saying "the occupation authority and Fatah are accomplices in the assassination."

The PA, meanwhile, also denounced the "assassination": Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad said in a statement that "the assassination is a grave escalation and enhances the existing distrust in the already shaky peace process."

Following the incident, Palestinian security forces have declared high alert, amid concerns that Hamas will retaliate by launching attacks in the West Bank.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3955654,00.html

Peace on Earth
18th September 2010, 01:32
Screw Israel and Hamas. Both use violent tactics against civilian populations that only result in more bloodshed. Not to mention they're both driven by, more or less, religious sentiments.

mosfeld
18th September 2010, 02:07
Screw Israel and Hamas. Both use violent tactics against civilian populations that only result in more bloodshed. Not to mention they're both driven by, more or less, religious sentiments.

Do you hold those resisting occupation and those occupying to the same standard?

Peace on Earth
18th September 2010, 22:53
Do you hold those resisting occupation and those occupying to the same standard?
Resisting occupation doesn't give you the right to kill innocent people who have no idea they're doing anything wrong.

IndependentCitizen
18th September 2010, 23:08
Resisting occupation doesn't give you the right to kill innocent people who have no idea they're doing anything wrong.
And much emphasis on the innocent children.

28350
18th September 2010, 23:10
Not to mention they're both driven by, more or less, religious sentiments.

Of course. The history of all hitherto existing societies is the history of religious struggles.
It's just Judaism vs. Islam.

manic expression
18th September 2010, 23:13
Resisting occupation doesn't give you the right to kill innocent people who have no idea they're doing anything wrong.
It's not that the Palestinian resistance wants to use tactics that put innocents in danger, it's that those tactics are the only tactics available to them. Plus, any and all overtures for cessation of hostilities has been mocked, slandered and/or broken by the Zionists. This is not a conflict that the Palestinians asked for or sought, but it is one they must win if they are to survive. That is why the Palestinian resistance is justified in its armed struggle of liberation against Zionism.

mosfeld
18th September 2010, 23:59
Resisting occupation doesn't give you the right to kill innocent people who have no idea they're doing anything wrong.

Liberal bullshit, of course. When will this shit die out?

Hamas have repeatedly stated that they solely target the IDF, settlers and politicians.

Reznov
19th September 2010, 00:12
Just remember everyone, Israel is a very peaceful country with a right for its existence!

Right.... right... right???

Sir Comradical
19th September 2010, 01:19
Resisting occupation doesn't give you the right to kill innocent people who have no idea they're doing anything wrong.

Pretty much no one here supports Hamas on ideological grounds. The fact is that Hamas was replaced by Fatah after being overthrown by Israel and the U.S in a coup. Ever since then, the area they still control (Gaza) has been subject to bombings and Hamas leaders have been routinely assassinated. Israel is the aggressor and occupier, Hamas is the democratically elected resistor and only militant option to represent and carry forth the Palestinian struggle. Equating the two amounts to a serious distortion of the conflict. As I've said before, there's nothing more unequal than the equal treatment of inequality.

Red Eagles
19th September 2010, 01:41
. It's just Judaism vs. Islam. If that's what the zionists want then they would seriously be on a losing battle.the fact is ,if that mentality prevails comrade-then who will win?
Palestine is not
about religion.although the reactionarys would like that.

Peace on Earth
19th September 2010, 18:26
Liberal bullshit, of course. When will this shit die out?

Hamas have repeatedly stated that they solely target the IDF, settlers and politicians.
And yet people who do not deserve to die, do. Even though they are Israeli, it is wrong to pretend that Hamas is perfect in its resistance. I support neither Israel nor Hamas, only oppressed people who wish to escape from said oppression.

mosfeld
19th September 2010, 19:01
And yet people who do not deserve to die, do. Even though they are Israeli, it is wrong to pretend that Hamas is perfect in its resistance. I support neither Israel nor Hamas, only oppressed people who wish to escape from said oppression. If you'd actually support oppressed people you'd support the Palestinians choice to use Hamas as their means to resist occupation and oppression, but instead you choice this vague liberal "middle way", pretending to support neither side, which is in turn supporting the status quo i.e the Israeli occupation.

Turinbaar
19th September 2010, 19:03
This essentially means nothing for palestinian liberation. Hamas is after all a total fabrication of the Israeli intelligence service meant to undermine the secular socialist resisters to the occupation, so anyone who supports them are to that extent supporting the state of Israel. Israel depends of the existence of jihadism to justify its occupation and expansionism, just as hamas depends on the prevalence of zionism to justify suicide bombings. The IDF kills another terrorist, Hamas claims conspiracy, and the Palestinians remain prisoners, in other words, "dog bites man."

Peace on Earth
19th September 2010, 19:05
If you'd actually support oppressed people you'd support the Palestinians choice to use Hamas as their means to resist occupation and oppression, but instead you choice this vague liberal "middle way", pretending to support neither side, which is in turn supporting the status quo i.e the Israeli occupation.
I don't support an Islamic organization that is horribly misguided in its direction of militant resistance. I'm all for militant action against an oppressive state, but for god sakes, attack the right targets. All Hamas is doing is breeding resentment by painting themselves as a terrorist organization. If they would attack the right targets, it would give opposition forces less ammo to smear them with in the media. The bloody body of a child isn't the best PR campaign.

mosfeld
19th September 2010, 19:16
This essentially means nothing for palestinian liberation. Hamas is after all a total fabrication of the Israeli intelligence service meant to undermine the secular socialist resisters to the occupation, If you're talking about Fatah then please let me direct you to this (http://www.revleft.com/vb/fatah-collaborationist-israeli-t141649/index.html) article.


Israel depends of the existence of jihadism to justify its occupation and expansionism, just as hamas depends on the prevalence of zionism to justify suicide bombings. Lol.
Israel's agenda = Zionism
Hamas' agenda = suicide bombing.

Are you joking?

Also, how do you explain that conclusion when the Palestinian resistance was predominantly secular?

Turinbaar
19th September 2010, 20:13
If you're talking about Fatah then please let me direct you to this (http://www.revleft.com/vb/fatah-collaborationist-israeli-t141649/index.html) article.

not fatah, the PFLP/PLO


Lol.
Israel's agenda = Zionism
Hamas' agenda = suicide bombing.

To be more specific hamas's agenda is rejection of all jews from palestine. Suicide bombing is among one of their tactics.


Also, how do you explain that conclusion when the Palestinian resistance was predominantly secular?

It's easy, hamas does not represent the predominant secular majority of palestinian resistance. They are merely an opportunist clique of jihadists originally created by Israel to undermine the real resistance. Just because they seized the political leadership on the west bank does not make them legitimate representatives of the Palestinians, any more the Sharon or Netanyahu represent the average Israeli.

manic expression
19th September 2010, 20:56
And yet people who do not deserve to die, do. Even though they are Israeli, it is wrong to pretend that Hamas is perfect in its resistance. I support neither Israel nor Hamas, only oppressed people who wish to escape from said oppression.
No one here is saying Hamas is "perfect", far from it. But it's not about perfect, it's about justified. Palestinian resistance to Israel is justified and necessary and progressive..."perfect" never enters into the question.

You say you support "oppressed people", but as soon as those people do what is necessary to struggle for liberation, you condemn them for not being perfect. So really, your stated intention is theoretical and little more.