Log in

View Full Version : Are we living in a black hole?



x371322
23rd July 2010, 19:39
Maybe? According to one scientist.


Scientists trying to explain the universe’s accelerating expansion usually point to dark energy, which seems to be pushing everything apart.
But an Indiana University professor has a new theory, reports New Scientist: We're inside a black hole that exists in another universe. Specifically, a black hole that rebounded, somewhat like a spring.
Some fairly mind-blowing physics is involved here, but the gist is that Nikodem Poplawski of IU-Bloomington used a modified version of Einstein’s general relativity equation set that takes particle spin into account.
Including this variable makes it possible to calculate torsion, part of the geometry of space-time. It also gets rid of the black hole singularity, a phenomenon that general relativity cannot explain.
In a study published earlier this year, Poplawski said when the density of matter reaches epic proportions, torsion counters gravity. This prevents matter from compressing indefinitely to a singularity of infinite density. Instead, matter rebounds like a spring, and starts expanding again.

In Poplawski's latest study, his calculations show that space-time inside the black hole expands to about 1.4 times its smallest size in as little as 10-46 seconds -- two orders of magnitude faster, for lack of a better word, than the Planck time. This brisk bounce-back could have been what led to the expanding universe that we see today.
But here's the real kicker: as Poplawski says, we may not be living in our universe at all; we might be living inside a rebounded black hole that exists in a different universe.


http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2010-07/we-might-be-living-black-hole-scientist-says

The Fighting_Crusnik
23rd July 2010, 19:46
Anything is possible since we know so little about our universe. Hell, there is some support for the idea that there is a red dwarf star named Nemesis about a light year or two rotating our sun simply because the earth has a massive extincition period once every 26-27 million years, which would be explained by the red dwarf's gravity propelling rocks inward with our sun pulling them its direction. Also, scientists don't even really know what the oort could exists, yet it does and some think that Nemesis could be responsible for this too. So we just simply don't know. One thing that is, for the most part certain, is that there are probably an infinite amount of universes in the Multi-verse.

eyedrop
23rd July 2010, 21:21
One thing that is, for the most part certain, is that there are probably an infinite amount of universes in the Multi-verse.
As far as I was aware we're not in any way certain that there are a multiverse, just that some models presume it.

AK
24th July 2010, 02:17
http://www.popsci.com.au/wp-content/themes/popsci/images/under_construction.jpg
fuuuuuuu-

nip
24th July 2010, 03:35
Man, If that was true it would be so cool every day would remind me of soundgarden

x371322
24th July 2010, 03:47
fuuuuuuu-

I was about to ask what you're talking about. But when I viewed the image, I noticed it took me to the Australian version of the site. I guess it must be redirecting you there, and screwing things up somehow. I'll edit my OP and post the article right there.

danyboy27
28th July 2010, 13:12
are we living in a black hole? that would explain the shit all around us.

Coggeh
29th July 2010, 04:39
The question is of a certain irrelevance because to prove it ,it would mean actually sending a probe or w/e into a black hole and since nothing can travel through a black hole because of the fact that space-time slows and slows so for any universe to form inside one or anything to go into it, it would take an infinite amount of time therefore pretty impossible:(

x371322
29th July 2010, 19:09
The question is of a certain irrelevance because to prove it ,it would mean actually sending a probe or w/e into a black hole and since nothing can travel through a black hole because of the fact that space-time slows and slows so for any universe to form inside one or anything to go into it, it would take an infinite amount of time therefore pretty impossible:(

I wouldn't say irrelevant. Maybe not really that useful to us (at least not yet :D), but I don't believe that any scientific knowledge can ever be irrelevant. Anything that furthers our understanding of the universe is always worth knowing. Of course this is only a hypothesis of one scientist... and just something to think about.

Tatarin
2nd August 2010, 03:27
Hmm, but what about the immense gravity? And shouldn't there be a continuous "big bang" (or "other side" of the black hole) from where all matter comes?

Masta Chief
30th August 2010, 03:58
There are muti-universes and I believe it. And I believe we as a people might end up in another universe. Only time time can tell if that will come true.

leftace53
30th August 2010, 04:02
I believe we now have a decent amount of certainty that there is a black hole at the center of our galaxy. So if aren't living in a black hole right now, we will someday :lol:

Tablo
30th August 2010, 04:11
I believe we now have a decent amount of certainty that there is a black hole at the center of our galaxy. So if aren't living in a black hole right now, we will someday :lol:
I thought it was twin black holes that are rotating around eachother.. damn I need to crack open a science book some time.

leftace53
30th August 2010, 04:16
I thought it was twin black holes that are rotating around eachother.. damn I need to crack open a science book some time.

uhh maybe. I haven't cracked one open in months now. I've just skimmed some online articles. I also have to hit the science books.

kitsune
30th August 2010, 22:59
I believe we now have a decent amount of certainty that there is a black hole at the center of our galaxy. So if aren't living in a black hole right now, we will someday :lol:

There is a supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy, and most others.

We don't have binary supermassive black holes, but some others like Galaxy 0402+379 do, probably resulting from the merging of galaxies. The new system formed from the merger of our galaxy with Andromeda will wind up with binary supermassive black holes.