Log in

View Full Version : Marxist/socioeconomic interpretation of Manifest Destiny?



gestalt
19th June 2010, 02:45
Let me preface this by saying that I have used and enjoyed the resources provided by this forum for a few years and appreciate the body of contributions from its members.

Now to brass tacks, I am looking for a substantial secondary source (preferably academic article or other well-cited publication) which provides, as the title states, a primarily materialist or economic analysis of the conditions behind American Manifest Destiny and/or Western expansionism.

In my searches of archives like JSTOR I have come across works replete with political, ideological and military evaluations of its justifications, but economic basis is mostly reduced to the allure of territory and resources. I need something a little more significant for my studies.

Zinn's chapter "We Take Nothing by Conquest, Thank God" among others was a good jumping off point, but would prefer recommendations which are more "scholarly."

Thanks in advance comrades.

¿Que?
19th June 2010, 03:03
Let me preface this by saying that I have used and enjoyed the resources provided by this forum for a few years and appreciate the body of contributions from its members.

Now to brass tacks, I am looking for a substantial secondary source (preferably academic article or other well-cited publication) which provides, as the title states, a primarily materialist or economic analysis of the conditions behind American Manifest Destiny and/or Western expansionism.

In my searches of archives like JSTOR I have come across works replete with political, ideological and military evaluations of its justifications, but economic basis is mostly reduced to the allure of territory and resources. I need something a little more significant for my studies.

Zinn's chapter "We Take Nothing by Conquest, Thank God" among others was a good jumping off point, but would prefer recommendations which are more "scholarly."

Thanks in advance comrades.
Is the Zinn book cited. You might want to look there....

gestalt
19th June 2010, 03:16
Unfortunately the version I am using is not, there is a substantial amount of quotes from primary sources, mostly Congressional speeches and accounts of soldiers from the Mexican-American War, of which I have tracked down and read a few.

I should have mentioned that I also consulted Beard's The Rise of American Civilization as well, but would appreciate more recent scholarship.

My primary need is twofold: both a strengthening of my own understanding of American history and as part of a series of secondary source critique for a graduate course.