Log in

View Full Version : Polygraph testing has no scientific basis.



Revy
18th May 2010, 18:41
More info here. (http://antipolygraph.org/)

I was surprised to learn that the inventor of the polygraph believed plants could read human thoughts and that there was a conspiracy in the scientific community to suppress evidence of this unusual belief.

mikelepore
19th May 2010, 02:24
It's based on the assumption: If you got nervous when you answered that question, your answer must have been a lie. It's as if they never heard of getting nervous when you tell the truth because you're afraid that the others might not believe you, which every human being has experienced.

The Gallant Gallstone
19th May 2010, 03:27
Hannah Arendt had something interesting to say regarding lie detectors in her Origins of Totalitarianism:

The lie detector is perhaps the most graphic example of the fascination that this dream apparently exerts over the mentality of all policemen; for obviously the complicated measuring equipment can hardly establish anything except the cold-blooded or nervous temperament of its victims. Actually, the feeble-minded reasoning underlying the use of this mechanism can only be explained by the irrational wish that some form of mind reading were possible at all. (p.131)

anticap
19th May 2010, 03:42
the inventor of the polygraph believed plants could read human thoughts

Well, they can blog (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/7681966.stm)....

Zapatas Guns
19th May 2010, 03:45
I always thought it was funny that in the U.S. a polygraph test is not admissible in court, but to become a government agent or in a host of other private businesses a person must be subjected to a polygraph exam.

There is work being done on real mind reading devices. The American and Israeli governments are very interested in them. It works this way: They have a big picture of someone you are not supposed to like, ie bin Laden. If it does not evoke certain response in your brain then you must be a terrorist!

I tried to post a bunch of links to the company that makes this technology and the governments that are interested in it but my post count is too low. :( Anyway I expect the TSA to get this soon.

"A polygragh is able to tell if a person is being truthful or not and the WeCU (We See You) will be able to tell what a person may be up by their body language being analyzed by the system.