Capitalism ===> Socialism ===> Collectivist Anarchism ===> Communism ?

[Che a chara]

While in practice it's impossible to have communism (real communism) in just one country, would it be possible to have the theory of collectivist anarchism proceed the stage of socialism for a better phasing out period before communism ?

[Die Rote Fahne]

While in practice it's impossible to have communism (real communism) in just one country, would it be possible to have the theory of collectivist anarchism proceed the stage of socialism for a better phasing out period before communism ?


No. Read the manifesto. Nao!

[Che a chara]

No. Read the manifesto. Nao!

I understand that it's not the procedure, but what practical reasons are there for the theory of collectivist anarchism being implemented after socialism not to be a possibility ?

I'm not at all saying that it is possible, just enquiring like:

How can one country have communism ?

If world wide communism is to be a possibility what people are looking at then would be world wide socialism in every country at the same time first (no ?)
(this is probably for those of the marxist-leninist persuasion)

While those countries who are more developed and have reached a higher stage of socialism could the basic theories of collectivist anarchism not be put in place for this phasing period while the other countries develop ? communism is internationalism and it would be impossible to leave one country behind if we are looking for a revolution.....

anyone know what i'm getting at ? (if not blame the drink :blushing: )

[scarletghoul]

Hmm do you mean like a stateless version of socialism in one country ??

Anyway from a Leninist point of view I don't think it would be necessary. The moment the need for the state is gone is the moment the final stage of communism begins

[Che a chara]

Hmm do you mean like a stateless version of socialism in one country ??

yeah more or less. the masses will be class conscious and aware of their responsibilities.


Anyway from a Leninist point of view I don't think it would be necessary. The moment the need for the state is gone is the moment the final stage of communism begins

But that to me seems to be from a viewpoint of communism in one country. Not all countries develop at the same rate and the socialism stage can't go on forever, waiting till every country catches up.

Do you think it's possible to have communism in one country while others are still developing socialism ?