Communist
14th February 2010, 19:31
______________
Empire of Savagery in the Amazon (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t.html)
By GREG GRANDIN
February 12, 2010
The 19th-century doctrine of progress held slavery and capitalism to be incompatible. Coercion, liberals believed, violated the ideals of natural rights and free labor. Wage work, Marxists thought, was more profitable than forced work, and that alone would doom slavery. Then in 1904, nearly four decades after Appomattox, Roger Casement, an Irish-born career diplomat in the British Foreign Office, wrote his Congo report, revealing that King Leopold of Belgium had enriched himself by presiding over a rubber trade founded on pure cruelty. What has civilization itself been to them? Casement asked of Leopolds Congolese victims, 10 million of whom, by some estimates, had perished in but two decades. He himself had the answer: A thing of horror.
(http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t.html#secondParagraph) http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t_CA0/Grandin-t_CA0-articleInline.jpg (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Casement) From The Devil and Mr. Casement
Roger Casement (http://britishhistory.suite101.com/article.cfm/sir_roger_casement) in 1910.
THE DEVIL AND MR. CASEMENT One Mans Battle for Human Rights in South Americas Heart of Darkness
By Jordan Goodman
Illustrated. 322 pp. Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
The Devil and Mr. Casement, by Jordan Goodman, the author of several works of history, reconstructs the Casement investigation in the Putumayo region of the Amazon rain forest (http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/science/topics/forests_and_forestry/rain_forests/index.html?inline=nyt-classifier) that followed the Congo report. There, the Peruvian Julio Csar Arana ruled over a rubber empire of 10,000 square miles, and from 1910 to 1913, Casement exhausted himself trying to force the British government to take action against Arana and his London-incorporated Peruvian Amazon Company. He twice traveled to the Amazon, collecting evi*dence of whipping, torture, mass rape, mutilation, executions and the hunting of the regions Indians, whose population Casement calculated had fallen to 8,000 in 1911 from 50,000 in 1906.
Goodmans book adds to Casements reputation as a pioneer of the human rights movements tactics, including the on-the-spot investigation, the gathering of victims testimony and the leveraging of public outrage to spur reform. Casement was one of the first to use the phrase crime against humanity, and he judged Arana to be guilty of not merely slavery but extermination what later would be called genocide.
But Casements moral trajectory ran opposite to that of many modern human rights activists. Frances current foreign minister, Bernard Kouchner (http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/k/bernard_kouchner/index.html?inline=nyt-per), for example, dropped his youthful support for national liberation movements to embrace what some have criticized as humanitarian imperialism.
Casement tried at first to use the services of a foreign office to ease suffering. Yet he veered off what he called the high road to being a regular Imperialist jingo. His time in Congo and the Amazon deepened his sense of anti*colonial solidarity. I was looking at this tragedy, he said of Congolese slavery, with the eyes of another race the Irish a people once hunted themselves. Knighted in 1911 for his humanitarian work, he was hanged by the British five years later for conspiring with the Germans on behalf of Irish independence.
Casements execution is not the climax of Goodmans story, because this book doesnt have a climax. It tapers off without resolution. The British directors of Aranas company are interrogated by members of Parliament. Reports are issued, sermons are preached, politicians are outraged. Arana appears before Parliaments committee on the Putumayo, after which he boards a steamer back to Peru untouched. The reader is left to ponder the fate of his indigenous victims.
This is an apt ending to a fine and meticulous book, for a kind of slavery still remains in force in the Amazon. Thousands of workers, for instance, trapped in conditions nearly as dismal as those documented a century ago in the Putumayo, make the charcoal used to forge pig iron, which is then purchased by international corporations to produce the steel used in everyday products, including popular makes of cars.
Arana ultimately lost his company and died broke. Yet the devil continues to get the better of Mr. Casement.
Greg Grandin is the author, most recently, of Fordlandia: The Rise and Fall of Henry Fords Forgotten Jungle City.
_________________________________
Empire of Savagery in the Amazon (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t.html)
By GREG GRANDIN
February 12, 2010
The 19th-century doctrine of progress held slavery and capitalism to be incompatible. Coercion, liberals believed, violated the ideals of natural rights and free labor. Wage work, Marxists thought, was more profitable than forced work, and that alone would doom slavery. Then in 1904, nearly four decades after Appomattox, Roger Casement, an Irish-born career diplomat in the British Foreign Office, wrote his Congo report, revealing that King Leopold of Belgium had enriched himself by presiding over a rubber trade founded on pure cruelty. What has civilization itself been to them? Casement asked of Leopolds Congolese victims, 10 million of whom, by some estimates, had perished in but two decades. He himself had the answer: A thing of horror.
(http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t.html#secondParagraph) http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2010/02/14/books/review/Grandin-t_CA0/Grandin-t_CA0-articleInline.jpg (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Casement) From The Devil and Mr. Casement
Roger Casement (http://britishhistory.suite101.com/article.cfm/sir_roger_casement) in 1910.
THE DEVIL AND MR. CASEMENT One Mans Battle for Human Rights in South Americas Heart of Darkness
By Jordan Goodman
Illustrated. 322 pp. Farrar, Straus & Giroux.
The Devil and Mr. Casement, by Jordan Goodman, the author of several works of history, reconstructs the Casement investigation in the Putumayo region of the Amazon rain forest (http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/science/topics/forests_and_forestry/rain_forests/index.html?inline=nyt-classifier) that followed the Congo report. There, the Peruvian Julio Csar Arana ruled over a rubber empire of 10,000 square miles, and from 1910 to 1913, Casement exhausted himself trying to force the British government to take action against Arana and his London-incorporated Peruvian Amazon Company. He twice traveled to the Amazon, collecting evi*dence of whipping, torture, mass rape, mutilation, executions and the hunting of the regions Indians, whose population Casement calculated had fallen to 8,000 in 1911 from 50,000 in 1906.
Goodmans book adds to Casements reputation as a pioneer of the human rights movements tactics, including the on-the-spot investigation, the gathering of victims testimony and the leveraging of public outrage to spur reform. Casement was one of the first to use the phrase crime against humanity, and he judged Arana to be guilty of not merely slavery but extermination what later would be called genocide.
But Casements moral trajectory ran opposite to that of many modern human rights activists. Frances current foreign minister, Bernard Kouchner (http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/k/bernard_kouchner/index.html?inline=nyt-per), for example, dropped his youthful support for national liberation movements to embrace what some have criticized as humanitarian imperialism.
Casement tried at first to use the services of a foreign office to ease suffering. Yet he veered off what he called the high road to being a regular Imperialist jingo. His time in Congo and the Amazon deepened his sense of anti*colonial solidarity. I was looking at this tragedy, he said of Congolese slavery, with the eyes of another race the Irish a people once hunted themselves. Knighted in 1911 for his humanitarian work, he was hanged by the British five years later for conspiring with the Germans on behalf of Irish independence.
Casements execution is not the climax of Goodmans story, because this book doesnt have a climax. It tapers off without resolution. The British directors of Aranas company are interrogated by members of Parliament. Reports are issued, sermons are preached, politicians are outraged. Arana appears before Parliaments committee on the Putumayo, after which he boards a steamer back to Peru untouched. The reader is left to ponder the fate of his indigenous victims.
This is an apt ending to a fine and meticulous book, for a kind of slavery still remains in force in the Amazon. Thousands of workers, for instance, trapped in conditions nearly as dismal as those documented a century ago in the Putumayo, make the charcoal used to forge pig iron, which is then purchased by international corporations to produce the steel used in everyday products, including popular makes of cars.
Arana ultimately lost his company and died broke. Yet the devil continues to get the better of Mr. Casement.
Greg Grandin is the author, most recently, of Fordlandia: The Rise and Fall of Henry Fords Forgotten Jungle City.
_________________________________