Log in

View Full Version : Marx was right to emphasise economic causality



graffic
27th January 2010, 09:31
Not because everybody is obsessed with money, but because economics effects political, cultural, military, environmental and even personal influences upon social change and social attitudes.

I'm referring to liberal alternatives such as the "great man theory" of historical change, which stresses instead that decisive impact of individual leaders such as Hitler, Gandhi and Christ plays an important role.

There is also, with regard to the British Empire, the "peripheral theory", and the "internationalist theory" which suggests the Empires existence had less to do with capitalism and more to do with other factors such as the competitiveness among nations and their colonies.

I can't believe how many "liberals" fall for this stuff. Although there are other factors to consider in an historical analysis, Marx was right emphasise economics above anything else

trivas7
30th January 2010, 22:24
The economy is the collective aggregate of choices human beings make in their economy interest. Marxist social theory substitutes "society" for God and claims that its chief concern is the life of a disembodied entity, society. As far the life of the individual is concerned, his ethical duty is to be the selfless, rightless, and voiceless slave of any need, claim or demand made by those who speak for the collective. Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia are the historical tributes to this theory.

FSL
30th January 2010, 22:40
As far the life of the individual is concerned, his ethical duty is to be the selfless, rightless, and voiceless slave of any need, claim or demand made by those who speak for the collective.


The years you must have spent reading Marx really show, well done.
*Claps*

Drace
30th January 2010, 22:48
As far the life of the individual is concerned, his ethical duty is to be the selfless, rightless, and voiceless slave of any need, claim or demand made by those who speak for the collective.

People being able to guide their own actions. How horrible.

Nolan
31st January 2010, 00:46
The economy is the collective aggregate of choices human beings make in their economy interest. Marxist social theory substitutes "society" for God and claims that its chief concern is the life of a disembodied entity, society. As far the life of the individual is concerned, his ethical duty is to be the selfless, rightless, and voiceless slave of any need, claim or demand made by those who speak for the collective. Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia are the historical tributes to this theory.

That was the best fucking strawman EVER.


What does Nazi Germany have to do with Marxism? Please tell me you're not that stupid.