Log in

View Full Version : Haiti's Earthquake - A disaster everyone knew would happen



Yazman
18th January 2010, 12:41
Source: http://www.salon.com/technology/how_the_world_works/2010/01/13/haiti_catastrophe_waiting_to_happen/index.html

Snippet from source:



Within hours of the earthquake that devastated Haiti, the tweets were flying: Just a year earlier, Patrick Charles, a geologist at the University of Havana, had predicted that a major earthquake was imminent along the Enriquillo Fault Zone that runs under the nation's capital, Port-au-Prince.

"Conditions are ripe for major seismic activity in Port-au-Prince," he told the French-language Haitian newspaper, Le Matin in October 2008. "The inhabitants of the Haitian capital need to prepare themselves for an event which will inevitably occur... Thank God that science has provided instruments that help predict these types of events and show how we have arrived at these conclusions."

Barely a month later, after the catastrophic collapse of a school in Petionville, the mayor of Port-au-Prince warned that 60 percent of Haiti's buildings "were shoddily built and unsafe normally." A 2005 report from the Organization of American States' Department of Sustainable Development noted that "There is no national building code in Haiti." The loss of thousands of lives in flooding in 2004 was attributed in part to "the absence of land use zoning and building guidelines, and comprehensive enforcement mechanisms."
There is no mystery to this enormous disaster. As the Haitian Ambassador to the United States, Raymon Alcide Joseph, told CNN on Tuesday, "we had been expecting this catastrophe."
Haiti had been warned of the possibility of a major earthquake, and Haiti knew that its infrastructure was highly vulnerable. The real mystery, then, is whether anything could have been done to prevent, or at least ameliorate, the current nightmare. Or at least, that's the mostly unspoken subtext to all the chatter commenting on Patrick Charles' prescient prediction. How could we have let this happen?


Click the link for the full article.

So what does everybody think about this? It was clearly and widely known that there would be a massive earthquake in Haiti and there was zero preparation. Nobody helped them to prepare for or evacuate in case of such an event. We know that such preparation and evacuation is entirely possible - Cuba routinely does such things, and the government of the Philippines does pre-volcanic eruption.

Why was nothing done?

Atlanta
18th January 2010, 13:55
well considering that buildings were collapsing for no apparent reason before this earth quake I think this has been along time coming...http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27595445/

Its the same thing that caused the levees to brake in New Orleans, shotty construction in the rush for profit....not to mention either the un-willingness or the inability of the Haitian government to inspect such structures

Luís Henrique
18th January 2010, 14:46
Why was nothing done?

Because rebuilding a city to prevent the consequences of an earthquake requires money, which Haiti doesn't have. And because rebuilding a city to prevent the consequences of an earthquake requires more than one year, even if you have the money to do it.

Luís Henrique

Dimentio
18th January 2010, 15:05
well considering that buildings were collapsing for no apparent reason before this earth quake I think this has been along time coming...http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27595445/

Its the same thing that caused the levees to brake in New Orleans, shotty construction in the rush for profit....not to mention either the un-willingness or the inability of the Haitian government to inspect such structures

Some if not most of these buildings were either shacks or constructed in the 19th century and in dire need for renovation.

Yehuda Stern
18th January 2010, 16:00
Similar things took place before the tsunami in SE Asia a couple of years back. I don't think it's a technical problem like Luis suggested. I think the imperialist states simply don't give a damn about the lives of the people in the third world and figure they have more to earn by letting the disaster happen than prevent it.

NecroCommie
18th January 2010, 16:50
Shock doctorine (yes I am reading that book right now)

bajo.el.arco.del.sol
18th January 2010, 17:00
It seems to be the way the "aid industry" is structured and what donor/rich country governments are willing to fund. The further away from firefighting you get, the less money there is for it.

Sending troops to keep order? Our pleasure! We'll be there whether or not we're invited.

Search and rescue teams for a week? No problem, we'll get a few firefighters to volunteer and we'll even buy them plane tickets.

Food handouts for the first few months? Sure, as long as we can use an opportunity to dump surplus food produced by our heavily subsidised farmers rather than buying any of it locally.

Support for re-building people's livelihoods after a disaster? Much, much less. Why should I buy her a goat? She should buy her own damn goat!

Funding for what they call DRR (disaster risk reduction) is extremely limited, typically comes from specialised donors (e.g. DIP-ECHO), and is almost exclusively for cyclical disasters like hurricanes that happen every few years rather than something as rare as an earthquake. I've never ever heard of any DRR funding being spent on something as individual as retrofitting private homes. Given that people in the rich countries already complain about governments spending "our tax dollars" on helping poor people in other countries who are clearly corrupt and undeserving, there is no way that there would be any domestic for funding to make sure that they have safe housing - even though large-scale DRR funding would work out way cheaper in the long-term by making the impacts of disasters so much less... disastrous.

Atlanta
18th January 2010, 17:08
who all is giving aid anyway? i mean other than the US, are Cuba and Venezuela sending aid? what the Dominican Republics response?

Yazman
20th January 2010, 02:24
The French government has stated its attempts to deliver aid are being blocked by the USA which has refused permission for their aircraft and vessels to enter Haiti.

LeninistKing
20th January 2010, 04:30
Russian scientists said it was done by an Earthquake Weapon machine of The Navy. And i believe it, because US Imperialism along with its allies, Israel, Nato, Europe etc. are desperate for land-grabbing. And Haiti is a perfect place to install a military-base. Remember that their main goal was killing lots of Haitians, dissolving the Haitian state, bringing lots of Haitians to USA, another ones to Europe, and killing many of them with this earthquake-weapong machine. And then finally occupy the whole country, take it over, and install a hardcore fascistic state, just like Isra-Hell is today a fascist spartan regional imperialist state at the service of the top dog imperialists in this world.

.



Source: http://www.salon.com/technology/how_the_world_works/2010/01/13/haiti_catastrophe_waiting_to_happen/index.html

Snippet from source:



Click the link for the full article.

So what does everybody think about this? It was clearly and widely known that there would be a massive earthquake in Haiti and there was zero preparation. Nobody helped them to prepare for or evacuate in case of such an event. We know that such preparation and evacuation is entirely possible - Cuba routinely does such things, and the government of the Philippines does pre-volcanic eruption.

Why was nothing done?