Log in

View Full Version : Arab American students punished for "mocking 9-11"



Guerrilla22
9th January 2010, 03:47
http://abcnews.go.com/WN/US/michigan-students-reprimanded-shirts-mocking-911/story?id=9491502&cid=yahoo_pitchlist

A group of Arab-American high school students were reprimanded for wearing sweatshirts (http://abcnews.go.com/US/strict-dress-code-dozens-suspended-indiana/story?id=8417872)they made which school administrators said "distastefully" referenced the 9/11 terror attack (http://s3.amazonaws.com/911timeline/2001/abcnews091101.html) on the World Trade Center.
Eleven boys from Edsel Ford High School's graduating class of 2011 in Dearborn, Mich (http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/story?id=125244&page=1)., wore hooded sweatshirts to school Monday depicting the numeral 11 with windows drawn on each digit, so they looked like towers. Alongside the towers is a thunderbird, the school's mascot, flying towards them. The text below the images read "You can't bring us down."
"The whole design gave prominence to the 9/11 tragedy, and of course was very upsetting to staff and students," said Principal Hassane Jaafar in a statement.

School officials said the boys intended the shirts to be displays of class pride and did not understand that they would be perceived as offensive.
"After talking with the students, it became clear that there were no intentions of harm, rather a very inappropriate and distasteful attempt to draw attention to themselves and to the class of 2011," said Jaafar.
The principal said the sweatshirts were confiscated, the students were reprimanded and the principal planned to meet with the students' parents.
Some 300 people showed up at a Parent Teacher Student Association meeting Tuesday night at which administrators discussed the incident. Some parents supported Jaafar's decision to confiscate the shirts, but not suspend the boys, while others believe disciplinary action should have been taken, said Jennifer Browne, president of the PTSA.
"I support our principal and his handling of the situation" Browne told ABCNews.com. "But I know not everyone is happy with it. Some people chose to interpret the sweatshirts as support of terrorism or a threat of a terrorist attack."

Sasha
9th January 2010, 15:59
http://failblog.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/129072641999197326.jpg

didnt help somebody put it on failblog

Muzk
9th January 2010, 16:05
im pretty sure if they were white christian boys there wouldnt have been a problem

Guerrilla22
9th January 2010, 16:55
I would totally wear one of those around if I had one.

Dimentio
9th January 2010, 23:10
I actually think these sweaters were quite tasteless. It is not okay to celebrate human deaths or to jest about meaningless attacks which have basically destroyed thousands more lives than the original 3000.

gorillafuck
10th January 2010, 03:39
I actually think these sweaters were quite tasteless. It is not okay to celebrate human deaths or to jest about meaningless attacks which have basically destroyed thousands more lives than the original 3000.
It was 2,000, not 3,000.

Edit: Apparently it was 3,000. My bad.

The Red Next Door
10th January 2010, 03:43
when people are gonna get out of this post 9/11 mentality?

An archist
10th January 2010, 12:11
Just how is this mocking the attacks of 9-11?
"You can't bring us down" seems like a pretty patriottic message to me. Something like 'you can destroy those towers, but you can't destroy our spirit.'
But off course, if arab students wear this, it's something completely different.

"Red Scum"
10th January 2010, 12:47
Just how is this mocking the attacks of 9-11?
"You can't bring us down" seems like a pretty patriottic message to me. Something like 'you can destroy those towers, but you can't destroy our spirit.'
But off course, if arab students wear this, it's something completely different.

To be fair- context.

It was stupid, and I don't know what they expected. Its like (warning: bad example) being a black American and running round stealing things, eating fried chicken and watermelon and then making a fuss claiming you're being discriminated against.

The Ungovernable Farce
10th January 2010, 18:14
I think that black Americans can experience real discrimination even if they do steal things and eat fried chicken. That was a terrible example.

"Red Scum"
10th January 2010, 18:25
I think that black Americans can experience real discrimination even if they do steal things and eat fried chicken. That was a terrible example.

You missed my point. I know its an awful example, what I mean is that if you don't want to be discriminated against, don't actively fuel negative stereotypes against yourself.

bcbm
10th January 2010, 18:32
It was 2,000, not 3,000.


2,973 victims and the 19 hijackers died as a result of the attacks.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks

Dimentio
10th January 2010, 19:11
You missed my point. I know its an awful example, what I mean is that if you don't want to be discriminated against, don't actively fuel negative stereotypes against yourself.

People should learn to not judge stereotypes, but actions.

Sasha
10th January 2010, 19:13
if you don't want to be discriminated against, don't actively fuel negative stereotypes against yourself.

i think this is called blaming the victim

Pirate Utopian
10th January 2010, 19:51
eating fried chicken and watermelon and then making a fuss claiming you're being discriminated against.
Black people cant eat fried chicken or watermelon without asking to be discriminated against?

Lyev
10th January 2010, 20:35
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_attacks
But it became an excuse (albeit a rather weak one) for the west to get involved in the middle east.

Wanted Man
11th January 2010, 15:55
You missed my point. I know its an awful example, what I mean is that if you don't want to be discriminated against, don't actively fuel negative stereotypes against yourself.

Hey, stop being an irritating little cracker posting ignorant shit on the internet all day, because you are actively fuelling negative stereotypes against yourself. This is not discrimination, you're just asking for it. Whitey. :rolleyes:

Dr. Rosenpenis
13th January 2010, 01:19
To be fair- context.

It was stupid, and I don't know what they expected. Its like (warning: bad example) being a black American and running round stealing things, eating fried chicken and watermelon and then making a fuss claiming you're being discriminated against.

you evidently have no idea what racial discrimination is

Drace
13th January 2010, 01:22
If this happened in the Soviet Union, it'd be cited as evidence of how the government restricts opposition and political dissidents.

lines
13th January 2010, 02:01
Those shirts were not mocking the attacks and they were not disrespectful in any way. It seems like people mispercieved what the shirts were implying, and it seems that people mispercieved that because the students are arab.

danny bohy
13th January 2010, 02:08
I wish i had one of those shirts.

Luís Henrique
26th January 2010, 18:18
http://failblog.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/129072641999197326.jpg

didnt help somebody put it on failblog

If the bird is the symbol of the school, then it seems a criticism of the school. Kinda: "your stupid teachers and classes can't bring down our wonderful spontaneity" (or ignorance, whatever).

It doesn't seem a good idea. It also doesn't seem something that would have stirred up so much drama if the students weren't Arab American.

Luís Henrique

Luís Henrique
26th January 2010, 18:19
I wish i had one of those shirts.

Want some money? Make some of those, and sell them. Your advertising campaign is already done, and paid for.

Luís Henrique