Log in

View Full Version : Review of Hardt and Negri, Commonwealth



themediumdog
16th October 2009, 13:50
"A cynic would say of this book that the authors are simply cashing in on a successful brand. After all, weren't we told in Multitude that it stood to their previous book as Hobbes' De Cive stood to his Leviathan? Hobbes didn't write a trilogy. Defending H&N against this cynic would be difficult, moreover, because there is really nothing new here. The same territory is covered as previously (and I mean exactly the same territory. I wouldn't be surprised if there are identical sentences). Any shift in focus is negligible."

etc.

Full review at: angeleconomics.blogspot.com/2009/10/review-of-hardt-and-negris-commonwealth.html

Lord Hargreaves
17th October 2009, 19:56
is this you reviewing the book, or is it just someone elses review that you liked?

themediumdog
19th October 2009, 12:47
little me