Log in

View Full Version : Barack Obama and the Future of American Politics



GPDP
28th September 2009, 08:34
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1594516316/ref=ox_ya_oh_product

A book by leftist historian Paul Street.

This book examines Obama's career, his political stances and values, and the phenomenon that took the United States by storm, culminating in his election to the U.S. Presidency (though this book was written a few months before that), as well as the reasons for why that phenomenon came to be and why Obama became such a favorite within our ruling institutions. It leaves no stone unturned in wading through Obama's record in the Senate, as well as closely examining his speeches and writings throughout his political career, from his start in politics as an Illinois state senator, to his best-selling book, The Audacity of Hope, to his intense presidential campaign.

Make no mistake: it is a highly critical book. Street bases his analysis from a left-wing socialist point of view, and demolishes the contemporary myths (which Street foresees will undoubtedly come up later) that Obama is a "socialist," or any kind of progressive for that matter. Instead, he lets Obama's record, his speeches, and his writings speak for themselves, and thus identify him squarely within the mainstream ideological spectrum, indeed well to the right of center on a variety of issues (most notably that of racism and imperialism, on which Obama is particularly conservative). It gives credit where it is due, and denounces those statements and actions Street deems as particularly reactionary.

In the end, Street stays shy of claiming that an Obama presidency would be utterly worthless or even reactionary, as he sees a glimmer of hope of progressive grassroots movements pushing Obama to the left. But whether or not you agree with that analysis, I believe the book is enjoyable and supremely informative in helping debunk much of Obama's image, whether it is Obama the messianic progressive as his left-liberal supporters naively see him, or Obama the traitorous socialist (i.e. uppity black man) as his right-wing conservative/racist/proto-fascist detractors dishonestly brand him. I highly recommend everyone read it.

Pogue
28th September 2009, 09:26
If I was going to read any book on Obama it would have to be from the perspective you say this is from. Interesting something like this has come out.

GPDP
28th September 2009, 18:35
If I was going to read any book on Obama it would have to be from the perspective you say this is from. Interesting something like this has come out.

It's one of the very few books critical of Obama from a left-wing perspective, as far as I know. It seems most literature is either gushingly supportive of him or critical of him but from a reactionary point of view (i.e. right-wing bullshit). Paul Street is also a very prolific critic of Obama, constantly writing articles about him and his policies on Znet.

A little bit on Paul Street, for those unfamiliar with him: he identifies with the libertarian socialist tradition, drawing his ideas from the likes of Marx, Luxemburg, Rocker, and Chomsky, to name a few. He is also an avowed anti-racist, and has written books on black poverty, racism, and oppression in Chicago. He is especially hard on Obama's stance (or more accurately, non-stance) on contemporary racism.

Street is particularly adept at drawing his analysis from statistics and what is actually said and done. He does well to contrast Obama's progressive-sounding slogans with his actual policy positions, as well as with statistics that contradict some of his more dubious claims.

To such an end, he has come to the conclusion that Obama is far more conservative than he is widely perceived as being in the mainstream (outside the ruling class, of course, who realize they have in Obama someone they can trust). But even if the opposite is true, and Obama actually holds more progressive principles than he lets on to people that pay attention (and I don't believe that is the case; I believe Obama is a thoroughly bourgeois politician), he is nevertheless constrained by the system he currently heads, so whatever his real values may be, any meaningful change will only be enacted if he is pushed by a large, organized social movement to do so.

Again, I cannot recommend this book enough to fellow leftists. I already knew Obama was not to be trusted, but some of the stuff the books points out that Obama said and did, as well as the people he cozied up to for campaign funds during his political career really surprised me, and further cemented my opposition to him. Top notch book IMO.

Pogue
28th September 2009, 19:36
It's one of the very few books critical of Obama from a left-wing perspective, as far as I know. It seems most literature is either gushingly supportive of him or critical of him but from a reactionary point of view (i.e. right-wing bullshit). Paul Street is also a very prolific critic of Obama, constantly writing articles about him and his policies on Znet.

A little bit on Paul Street, for those unfamiliar with him: he identifies with the libertarian socialist tradition, drawing his ideas from the likes of Marx, Luxemburg, Rocker, and Chomsky, to name a few. He is also an avowed anti-racist, and has written books on black poverty, racism, and oppression in Chicago. He is especially hard on Obama's stance (or more accurately, non-stance) on contemporary racism.

Street is particularly adept at drawing his analysis from statistics and what is actually said and done. He does well to contrast Obama's progressive-sounding slogans with his actual policy positions, as well as with statistics that contradict some of his more dubious claims.

To such an end, he has come to the conclusion that Obama is far more conservative than he is widely perceived as being in the mainstream (outside the ruling class, of course, who realize they have in Obama someone they can trust). But even if the opposite is true, and Obama actually holds more progressive principles than he lets on to people that pay attention (and I don't believe that is the case; I believe Obama is a thoroughly bourgeois politician), he is nevertheless constrained by the system he currently heads, so whatever his real values may be, any meaningful change will only be enacted if he is pushed by a large, organized social movement to do so.

Again, I cannot recommend this book enough to fellow leftists. I already knew Obama was not to be trusted, but some of the stuff the books points out that Obama said and did, as well as the people he cozied up to for campaign funds during his political career really surprised me, and further cemented my opposition to him. Top notch book IMO.

That actually sounds quality, really good, thanks mate, I'll probably actually buy that after I've got through Africa Altered States Ordinary Miracles and Behan's stuff, I've been looking for a good analysis of Obama.