Log in

View Full Version : Four family members die after utility shut-off



Communist
28th July 2009, 14:26
this tragic story is found here (http://www.workers.org/2009/us/shutoff_0730/)

============================
========================

Family, community blame DTE as
Four family members die after utility shut-off

By Bryan G. Pfeifer
Detroit

Published Jul 27, 2009 10:02 PM


The greed of DTE Energy Co. led to the July 16 deaths of four members of an African-American family in Detroit. The Reed-Owens family had their electricity cut off on July 15 by DTE for nonpayment.

http://www.workers.org/2009/us/shutoff_0730.jpg

From left, DeMarco, Mar'Keisha
and DeMonte as a toddler.

The family was desperate when their power was cut off because several family members suffered from serious medical conditions—including asthma, neurofibromatosis and bronchitis—and required the use of electric breathing machines.

The Reed-Owenses went to their church to borrow a gas-powered generator which they placed in their basement, unaware of the danger of doing so. Only hours later four of the five family members died due to suspected carbon monoxide poisoning. The mother, Marquetta Owens, was the only survivor. Her partner, Vaughn Reed, and their children Mar’Keisha Reed, 17, DeMarco Owens, 12, and DeMonte Owens, 6, perished in their home. (Detroit News, July 17).

Like millions of other families in the United States, the Reed-Owens family, through no fault of their own, had fallen victim to unemployment. Mr. Reed was laid off from an auto parts supplier in January, which created many financial hardships for the family, including the foreclosure of their home.

The Reed-Owens tragedy is particularly heart-wrenching and outrageous as the family had filed for bankruptcy protection, making it illegal for DTE to shut off their utilities. The U.S. Bankruptcy Court on June 25 sent DTE an electronic notification of the Reed-Owens bankruptcy filing. But DTE didn’t stop the shutoff. Instead the corporation claims the shutoff notice was sent to the wrong address—not to the home where the Reed-Owenses resided.

Although Reed telephoned DTE on July 15 and told the company he had filed for bankruptcy, power wasn’t restored immediately. DTE claimed it was going to turn the power back on the next day, but by then it was too late.

Neighbors and family members of the Reed-Owenses are outraged and aghast over DTE’s criminal actions. “At these times of crisis, what is the problem?” asked Pamela Jackson, Owen’s cousin, who said DTE never should have turned off the power.

People before profits! Utilities are a right!

DTE Energy is a monopoly corporation whose 2008 operating revenues were $9.3 billion. The company claims over $24 billion in assets and $546 million in net income, according to its 2008 financial filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

DTE’s two primary utilities are Detroit Edison, an electric utility with 2.2 million customers in Michigan, and the Michigan Consolidated Gas Company (MichCon), its natural gas utility with 1.3 million customers.

DTE’s board of directors is crawling with Chrysler, Ford, Comerica Bank and other corporate thieves, including investment “advisors” and a former general who worked for the Pentagon and the Army’s 1st Infantry Division. (www.dteenergy.com (http://www.dteenergy.com))

Despite the corporation’s slogan of “making dreams real,” the reality is that DTE’s top priority is making profits, no matter what the consequences are in terms of life and death for real people who need gas and electricity.


========================================
-------------------------------------








Articles copyright 1995-2009 Workers World. Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.

Bitter Ashes
28th July 2009, 15:19
That is horrific and barbaric to the extreme. Wait until Winter and you'll see even more deaths directly attributed to utility shutoffs. I myself had no heating throughout winter before last and I was certain at times that I was going to die. If it hadnt been for me finding somewhere warm to sleep when the tempartures went to -14 degrees I probably would have.

Food, utilities and shelter are the most basic of human rights. It disgusts me to no end that capitalists attach a price tag to them. What next? Pay for your air?

Rjevan
28th July 2009, 21:26
Though I should know better I'm always shocked how ruthless capitalists act when it comes to money; no mercy for anybody, no interest for the reasons which led to this situation, no interest for circumstances - if you can't pay your worthless and therefore deserve not even the most basic rights anymore, that's it, end of story.

This is so bitter! First people are driven to ruin through the greed of the capitalists who caused the financial crisis and then they get punished for being ruined and in this case even die for the insatiable greed of those who have caused that everything got so worse. I fear Ranma is right and this won't stay an exception.
"Capitalism kills" gets confirmed once again in a sad and impressive way.

Communist
29th July 2009, 19:26
"Capitalism kills" gets confirmed once again

Truer words were never spoken, comrade. This is an outrage.

*Red*Alert
29th July 2009, 19:40
That is a disgraceful and pointless loss of life, caused by nothing other than greed! I cannot express my anger in words at such a pointless waste of human life.

Are those on here still opposed to my Capitalism > Explosions > Socialism strategy?

PRC-UTE
29th July 2009, 19:49
My god that's sad :(

HeartlessLibertarian
30th July 2009, 01:36
Yes, any lost of life, much less a family with children in tragic. However, the energy company didn't know their was important medical needs in that house so how can you blame them? Thousands of people a day get their power shut off for failure to pay their bill. When you buy a service with a company like that, you enter a contract to pay your bill on time, if you dont pay it then you get the service shut off.

Yes, its horrible, but you can't blame the energy company. Hell, there is a sign on the side of every generator that says Dont Run Indoors because of that very reason.

SocialismOrBarbarism
30th July 2009, 01:53
When you buy a service with a company like that, you enter a contract to pay your bill on time, if you dont pay it then you get the service shut off.

Yes, its horrible, but you can't blame the energy company. Hell, there is a sign on the side of every generator that says Dont Run Indoors because of that very reason.

Sure we can:


The Reed-Owens tragedy is particularly heart-wrenching and outrageous as the family had filed for bankruptcy protection, making it illegal for DTE to shut off their utilities.

War Cry
30th July 2009, 02:04
So,

What projects in each of our cities do we organize to counteract the death of capitalism come winter?

This tragedy is just one of many. One of millions that go unreported, undiscovered, and isn't sensationalized by the news. If it tugs at your heartstrings, which direction does it pull them?

Communist
30th July 2009, 15:41
What projects in each of our cities do we organize to counteract the death of capitalism come winter?
This tragedy is just one of many. One of millions that go unreported, undiscovered, and isn't sensationalized by the news. If it tugs at your heartstrings, which direction does it pull them?

Towards demonstrations, marches, letters/emails to politicians, utility companies, social leaders, internet awareness, there's a lot we can do.
If you live in Michigan (I do not) and need contact info, try this (http://www.moratorium-mi.org/).
If you're outside of Michigan, go here. (http://bailoutpeople.org/)
Contact the national office or the nearest local center, and tell them you want to get involved, and in what struggles.
Thank you.

(http://bailoutpeople.org/)

Communist
31st July 2009, 03:19
Yes, any lost of life, much less a family with children in tragic. However, the energy company didn't know their was important medical needs in that house so how can you blame them? Thousands of people a day get their power shut off for failure to pay their bill. When you buy a service with a company like that, you enter a contract to pay your bill on time, if you dont pay it then you get the service shut off.

It doesn't say anywhere that the utility company was unaware of the medical conditions, of course they were.
They appear to be claiming they weren't aware of the bankruptcy filing.
But hey, the bill wasn't paid, so...that's capitalism and fair's fair by your logic.


[/QUOTE]Yes, its horrible, but you can't blame the energy company. Hell, there is a sign on the side of every generator that says Dont Run Indoors because of that very reason.[/QUOTE]

I can blame the energy company for shutting off the power on the family in the first place, especially when illness is involved. I suppose I can't blame those billionaires if there was or was not a label on the generator, but if it wasn't for them turning off the power, it wouldn't have been used at all.

At least you think it's tragic and horrible.
--> I imagine most capitalists will say that, though.