Log in

View Full Version : Society: Why?



Wonderer
9th April 2009, 02:57
Why should society exist?

What should society strive for?

Taking the broadest of perspectives, our ancestors lived communally simply for survival purposes. There are safety in numbers, food is more easily found with more eyes and brains, reproduction is expanded.

We live in society because it makes sense. by working together, sharing and trading knowledge and goods we can create more for ourselves than if living in some mountain shack.

Basically we seek to make our lives better; it's easier.

We as humans want easy lives. We want easy lives because a minimization of displeasure means there is more room for pleasure, which by definition is good.

I could say society should be about creating an easy life, but i think that is still a bit narrow.

Why is an easy painless life good? why is pleasure good?

It is an effect on our consciousness. They affect our moods, our level of happiness, and our very thoughts.

There is an inherent value in every conscious human. Each person experiences both pain and pleasure, both positive and negative emotions. Each person has their own set of desires. Everybody values themselves and values something.

When it comes down to it, it makes sense to live communally because it furthers our desires, which makes us happy.

In this sense society ought to be about producing happiness...

Not like Spocks needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few codswallop. One persons happiness or displeasure should not be placed above or below the happiness or displeasure of 1, 10, 100, 100, or one million people (etc..)...

Put yourself in the shoes of the one person who is supposed to die.

...

It's possible to consider every action selfish...

It never was "ask yourself what you can do for your country"

It always was and always will be "GOD DAMMIT COUNTRY GIVE ME MORE!!!"

And it ought to be so...

Now this may sound anti-socialist in the sense that people aren't easily persuaded with the idea of giving to the community, but once we see we are all eating from the same pot, we realize if we contribute more and take reasonable portions, we can all have more.

I guess I'm saying we're all hedonists in a way. I envy people living in the jungle working 3-4 hours a day chopping palm trees and shooting blow darts in spider monkeys. (too much?)

Dr.Claw
9th April 2009, 03:08
Why should society exist?

What should society strive for?

Taking the broadest of perspectives, our ancestors lived communally simply for survival purposes. There are safety in numbers, food is more easily found with more eyes and brains, reproduction is expanded.

We live in society because it makes sense. by working together, sharing and trading knowledge and goods we can create more for ourselves than if living in some mountain shack.

Basically we seek to make our lives better; it's easier.

We as humans want easy lives. We want easy lives because a minimization of displeasure means there is more room for pleasure, which by definition is good.

I could say society should be about creating an easy life, but i think that is still a bit narrow.

Why is an easy painless life good? why is pleasure good?

It is an effect on our consciousness. They affect our moods, our level of happiness, and our very thoughts.

There is an inherent value in every conscious human. Each person experiences both pain and pleasure, both positive and negative emotions. Each person has their own set of desires. Everybody values themselves and values something.

When it comes down to it, it makes sense to live communally because it furthers our desires, which makes us happy.

In this sense society ought to be about producing happiness...

Not like Spocks needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few codswallop. One persons happiness or displeasure should not be placed above or below the happiness or displeasure of 1, 10, 100, 100, or one million people (etc..)...

Put yourself in the shoes of the one person who is supposed to die.

...

It's possible to consider every action selfish...

It never was "ask yourself what you can do for your country"

It always was and always will be "GOD DAMMIT COUNTRY GIVE ME MORE!!!"

And it ought to be so...

Now this may sound anti-socialist in the sense that people aren't easily persuaded with the idea of giving to the community, but once we see we are all eating from the same pot, we realize if we contribute more and take reasonable portions, we can all have more.

I guess I'm saying we're all hedonists in a way. I envy people living in the jungle working 3-4 hours a day chopping palm trees and shooting blow darts in spider monkeys. (too much?)
Might I suggest you talk to somebody experienced in philosophy.

Dr.Claw
9th April 2009, 03:20
Because one can never have sex with oneself.
Thats funny... somebody told me to go fuck myself.

Wonderer
9th April 2009, 03:31
Because one can never have sex with oneself.

no but you can leave afterward...


Dr.Claw, I am adept in philosophy, i was just trying to adapt some of them for practical use.

If you could just give me your opinion, i would be more than grateful.

Philosophy is something we all practice.

Unregistered
9th April 2009, 03:54
As in, we all masturbate.

Sure we do. We masturbate for pleasure.

We analyze and philosophize to solve problems... to get pleasure...

We chase happiness...

Dr.Claw
9th April 2009, 03:59
no but you can leave afterward...


Dr.Claw, I am adept in philosophy, i was just trying to adapt some of them for practical use.

If you could just give me your opinion, i would be more than grateful.

Philosophy is something we all practice.
Hmmm...I think society is really just inevitable, as long people are around each other they will socialize and band together as societies, its just our species.

Invincible Summer
9th April 2009, 08:52
Why should society exist? etc etc etc etc



At first I thought I could try to answer from a sociological standpoint, but it's way too philosophical for me to even try to answer at this hour.



It's possible to consider every action selfish...

It never was "ask yourself what you can do for your country"

It always was and always will be "GOD DAMMIT COUNTRY GIVE ME MORE!!!"

And it ought to be so...

Well, that phrase was used to mean "country = the state."

And there's nothing wrong with some selfish tendencies - it's natural. And I think most reasonable Communists understand this. Communism doesn't seek to eradicate the individual and turn society into the Borg hive. Communism is about destroying oppressive and exploitative structures in society so that the individual can feel more free, yet at the same time connected to his/her society, as capitalism creates all sorts of ways to divide us from each other.

NecroCommie
9th April 2009, 11:33
Society exists as long as people talk to each other. Society is a group of people interacting with each other. State on the other hand is an artificial structure imposed upon the natural society.