Log in

View Full Version : “Are economic recessions inevitable?”



bailey_187
12th March 2009, 21:28
My school is making everyone in my year enter the "Young Economist of the Year" competition

This means we have to write a 2000 word essay on Are economic recessions inevitable?

I know the basics of Marx's theory of crisis but not well enough to write 2000 words on it

Please could everyone explain in the fullest detail you are willing to; why recessions are inevitable in capitalism? (I wont copy your work directly)

In the (very) unlikely event that i win, i will donate to the forum

(would there be somewhere better on the forum to post asking for essay help?)

cyu
13th March 2009, 19:05
I wouldn't make the argument that recessions are inevitable in capitalism. Instead, I would make the argument that recessions are NOT inevitable, as long as society is willing to abandon capitalism. It's a small difference, but it lifts the burden of proof on your part somewhat and makes your case easier to argue for.

The problem with the so-called "business cycle" is that it quite often is really just a series of economic bubbles.

First someone notices a small uptick in tulip bulb sales, so they pour a lot of money into buying tulip bulbs. This causes tulip bulb prices to edge upward some more. As more people notice this, more and more people jump on the tulip bulb bandwagon. Tulip bulb prices start to soar. People start thinking they'd be stupid not to invest in tulip bulbs at this point - it's sheep following sheep. Eventually, the people buying tulip bulbs for investment purposes far outnumber the people buying them to actually use - so it just becomes investors selling to more investors. The people who got in early make a killing - kind of like a pyramid scheme. Eventually the bubble pops and tulip bulb prices take a dive - suddenly there's mass unemployment in the tulip bulb industry - after all, during the bubble's hey-day, tons of people were being hired in the bulb industry.

So now that investors (at least the ones that haven't been wiped out by the tulip bulb crash) have pulled out all their money, what's next? Do they learn their lesson? No, not really. They're just looking for the next "investment opportunity". In fact, bubbles are an essential part of making money in the investment business. The goal is to get in on the next bubble early, and get out before you are burned.

So what's next? Well, how about the dot-com bubble? The housing bubble? The oil price bubble? This is what is usually called the capitalist "business cycle".

mykittyhasaboner
13th March 2009, 19:43
http://www.marxwasright.com/index.html

You should find much material to work with here.