What am i?

[Che_Guevara_]

communist or socialist

a classless state with no discrimination and equality for all. This is where our idea of communism may differ. Many south africans believe the version of communism that should be implemented into the country should have a sort of government. Sounds a contradiction but it isnt so simple, the natural instinct is to follow or to lead, to listen and to reply, power cannot be shared within the people without a sort oof leader like Stalin or Mao but without the strings attached like the great purge or like china now a kind of non-communism as china has a free-marketing system. So i would implement a President who would live like the common everyone else, a chancellor and a cabinet of ministers. They would be voted for by the population in the areas where they affect the public i.e head of state wouldnt be voted for by the population of neighbouring states like the USA.
I realise some of these ideas arent typical communist ideas but otherwise it wont work in practice + its just my opinion and after all i have alot to learn. However the president position is not up for election like a dictatorship but like i said without the stalinism.


so what am i because one member said this is socialist and one disagreed

[SocialismOrBarbarism]

communist or socialist

a classless state with no discrimination and equality for all. This is where our idea of communism may differ. Many south africans believe the version of communism that should be implemented into the country should have a sort of government. Sounds a contradiction but it isnt so simple, the natural instinct is to follow or to lead, to listen and to reply, power cannot be shared within the people without a sort oof leader like Stalin or Mao but without the strings attached like the great purge or like china now a kind of non-communism as china has a free-marketing system. So i would implement a President who would live like the common everyone else, a chancellor and a cabinet of ministers. They would be voted for by the population in the areas where they affect the public i.e head of state wouldnt be voted for by the population of neighbouring states like the USA.
I realise some of these ideas arent typical communist ideas but otherwise it wont work in practice + its just my opinion and after all i have alot to learn. However the president position is not up for election like a dictatorship but like i said without the stalinism.


so what am i because one member said this is socialist and one disagreed

You can't have socialism without democracy. So, no.

[Pogue]

communist or socialist

a classless state with no discrimination and equality for all. This is where our idea of communism may differ. Many south africans believe the version of communism that should be implemented into the country should have a sort of government. Sounds a contradiction but it isnt so simple, the natural instinct is to follow or to lead, to listen and to reply, power cannot be shared within the people without a sort oof leader like Stalin or Mao but without the strings attached like the great purge or like china now a kind of non-communism as china has a free-marketing system. So i would implement a President who would live like the common everyone else, a chancellor and a cabinet of ministers. They would be voted for by the population in the areas where they affect the public i.e head of state wouldnt be voted for by the population of neighbouring states like the USA.
I realise some of these ideas arent typical communist ideas but otherwise it wont work in practice + its just my opinion and after all i have alot to learn. However the president position is not up for election like a dictatorship but like i said without the stalinism.


so what am i because one member said this is socialist and one disagreed

Its a totalitarian government claiming they're socialist. Its not socialist at all. If they implenented socialism there'd be no need for any leaders at all.

[Invincible Summer]

the natural instinct is to follow or to lead, to listen and to reply
Uh...


power cannot be shared within the people without a sort oof leader like Stalin or Mao but without the strings attached like the great purge or like chinaThat's a totalitarian dictatorship. Is that what you really want? Jesus fucking christ!


So i would implement a President who would live like the common everyone else, a chancellor and a cabinet of ministers. They would be voted for by the population in the areas where they affect the public i.e head of state wouldnt be voted for by the population of neighbouring states like the USA.
I realise some of these ideas arent typical communist ideas but otherwise it wont work in practice + its just my opinion and after all i have alot to learn. However the president position is not up for election like a dictatorship but like i said without the stalinism. So, is the President elected or not? You're contradicting yourself. If he's not elected, then how does he get into power?

And, IMO, you can't have a dictatorship like this without any purges or violence like in the USSR or PRC. If power is to be held so dearly by the President, he's going to crush opposition.



Regardless, your ideas are really abhorrent to me.

[scarletghoul]

Jamahiriya maybe? lol.

[Blackscare]

power cannot be shared within the people without a sort oof leader like Stalin or Mao but without the strings attached like the great purge or like china

Talk about naive, we'll just give absolute power to one guy and tell him not to abuse it? That's why people oppose totalitarianism, there's no telling what a leader might do, you can't just hope you get a benevolent king type. What you're saying sounds an awful like like archaic ideals used to justify monarchy, ie the idea of a benevolent absolute leader. That system failed because leaders can't be trusted with that kind of power.